Articles

Republicans Need A Health-Care Offensive

May 09, 2019
46e7aaadb3c104a3ac57bbaf0a5d3b1e

It’s the paradox of success. With 3.6% unemployment and 3.2% growth in gross domestic product, voters are turning to other issues. When the May 1 NBC/Wall Street Journal survey asked what “should be the top priority for the federal government,” 24% chose health care and 18% said immigration and border security. Job creation and growth came in third, at 14%. While this shouldn’t stop Republicans from selling their economic success, it points to a central challenge for 2020.

The GOP must narrow the Democratic health-care advantage. Too many people are too ready to believe that whatever Democrats offer on that front is better for the country. A Feb. 27 NBC/Wall Street Journal poll found 56% think the Democratic Party’s position on health care is “in the broad mainstream” while 41% believe the same of the Republican position.

The GOP’s health-care messaging should be grounded in one fact: Most Americans are satisfied with their coverage and want to keep it. A Nov. 11, 2018, Gallup poll found that 70% of Americans rated their coverage excellent or good. They want to repair, not replace, the health-care system.

One conservative group found in a private poll that, by better than 2 to 1, respondents in 12 battleground states agree that while “our health care system has problems, we should focus on what’s working and fix what’s broken, rather than starting from scratch and making massive changes.” They reject the proposition that “we need to start over with a new government system that will provide universal coverage and make health care a guaranteed right.”

Republicans should target the plan championed by Sen. Bernie Sanders and endorsed by other leading Democratic contenders. Call Medicare for All what it is—socialized medicine—and launch an offensive against it. The Republican strategy should have three components.

First is making a convincing case that Democrats are pushing a bad policy. Polling by center-right groups has identified many effective arguments. The Sanders proposal would be so expensive—an estimated $32 trillion for its first decade alone—that doubling all taxes on every person and every business wouldn’t be enough to pay for it. Plus, it will outlaw all private insurance. If you have problems getting care, you won’t be able to switch plans.

Since Medicare for All also abolishes Medicare, seniors would lose coverage they paid into all their lives, only to be forced into an inferior plan with everyone else. As in Canada, Britain and elsewhere, Americans would wait longer for appointments, face rationing, receive worse and less care, and be denied access to needed medication. There would also be fewer doctors, nurses and hospitals because Mr. Sanders’s plan would cut health-care reimbursements by 40%.

Second, Republicans must show that socialized medicine is out of sync with the nation’s values. Americans want to control their health care, not put government in charge. They want a relationship with their doctors, not Washington bureaucrats. They want choice and options, not one-size-fits-all. And they distrust government to run health care.

Making this case requires more than facts and numbers. Republicans must personalize their arguments with stories of ordinary people, including seniors who want to keep their Medicare Advantage policies, families whose employer-provided coverage meets their needs, and immigrants who know socialized medicine’s rationing and delays all too well.

 

Continue reading at WSJ.com

Related Article

1bc4f0ae8300992a28971577d64e874e
May 23, 2019 |
Article
We’re all watching a sci-fi movie in which ordinary human beings are infected by an alien pathogen. ...
1a8167938453df065a0cf9a7c5f8675a
May 16, 2019 |
Article
Even before Joe Biden announced he was running for president, pundits savaged him. A CNN editor at large dismissed the 76-year old as “a white man who has spent his entire professional life in elected office” running “to lead a party that is increasingly ...
B7f21c79df2090eb74316e5da2048c01
May 07, 2019 |
Article
The attempted Democratic takedown of Attorney General William Barr last week during his Senate Judiciary Committee appearance was a thing to behold.  ...
5d1b326101d54786ed317485f67ebf5d
May 02, 2019 |
Article
The first polls following the release of special counsel Robert Mueller’s report flash warning signs for congressional Democrats. It’s not looking good for their investigate-and-impeach strategy. ...
Button karlsbooks
Button readinglist
Button nextapperance