Articles

Here We Go Again: Debates Start Tuesday

September 24, 2020
51d6dd2df6da1d2dcfe94cc05ad743fd

On Tuesday night, President Trump and former Vice President Joe Biden will arrive on the health-education campus of Case Western Reserve University and the Cleveland Clinic to begin the first presidential debate of the general election. This “Clash in Cleveland” will have its own tempo and tone, but the 36 such debates since 1960 have elements in common.

Incumbents often do badly in the first debate, perhaps because after being president for four years, they wonder why they’re even sharing the stage with a challenger. Or maybe many challengers, with fewer demands on their time, come better prepared and psyched up.

Mitt Romney was widely thought to have manhandled President Barack Obama in 2012’s opening bout. President Ronald Reagan did so poorly in the first 1984 debate with Walter Mondale that news reports questioned whether, at 73, he was too old. Reagan answered that in the next debate with a joke: “I am not going to exploit, for political purposes, my opponent’s youth and inexperience.” (Mr. Mondale was 56.) Game, set, match.

Yet debates are rarely dispositive. It’s the unusual encounter—think the first Kennedy-Nixon debate in 1960—that bends the contest in a new direction. Sen. John F. Kennedy trailed going into that debate but won among people who watched on television, as Vice President Richard Nixon perspired with no makeup and a 5 o’clock shadow. JFK came across as elegant and in command. He emerged with a durable polling bump and went on to win narrowly.

Usually, though, debates tend to harden trends already present in the race. Take the second 1988 debate, when CNN’s Bernie Shaw asked Michael Dukakis, “If Kitty Dukakis, were raped and murdered, would you favor an irrevocable death penalty for the killer?” Historian John Pitney characterized Mr. Dukakis’s “robotic response”—“No, I don’t, Bernard”—as sounding “as if he were talking about Swedish land-use planning.” But this didn’t change the race’s trajectory. Mr. Dukakis had already fallen behind in August amid charges that he was too far left; the debate continued his slide.

Small gestures and actions are magnified by the moment. Al Gore’s sighing and eye-rolling while George W. Bush was speaking in the first debate of 2000, and Mr. Bush’s head nod in the third debate when Mr. Gore tried intimidating him by invading his space, left the impression that Mr. Gore was the insufferable, smarty-pants high-school debater every classmate detested. Appearing likable is key to winning the night.

Such moments can inform as well as obscure. The kerfuffle over President Gerald Ford’s 1976 denial that the Soviet Union dominated Eastern Europe took days to walk back, chewing up time that could have been devoted to better issues for Ford.

Expectations also matter. Each camp should lower them for its candidate and raise them for its opponent. That’s why Mr. Trump’s comments on Mr. Biden’s incoherence have been striking and why the Trump campaign recently shifted gears. Reports have surfaced of Mr. Trump privately and his team publicly reflecting on Mr. Biden’s long history of Senate and vice presidential debates, and his seasoning in this year’s dozen primary debates in which he held his own, even though Sen. Bernie Sanders held back in the final mano-a-mano contest because the race was over. That won’t be the case Tuesday, but Mr. Trump should be careful not to go over the top with personal attacks.

There will probably be memorable lines tagging an opponent’s weakness. Every candidate comes armed with some. They must be delivered naturally but are rarely as effective as Reagan’s “There you go again” retort to Jimmy Carter in 1980.

Read more at WSJ.com

Related Article

3cc0206620a21943a4c1eaa4b770910f
October 15, 2020 |
Article
The 2020 campaign has entered its stretch run. Though early voting just began, at least 14.9 million people have already cast a ballot. ...
2296f63364717155a9b99d1a2f7af53b
October 08, 2020 |
Article
If next week’s presidential debate occurs, it’ll likely be a doozy.  ...
070a40baf83423939f1dd7032242f0a0
October 01, 2020 |
Article
Well, that was different—really different. We’ve never seen anything quite like it ...
98b861ffa61c343cb98f37615556357d
September 17, 2020 |
Article
The presidential contest is the most important, but hardly the only critical battle this fall.  ...
Button karlsbooks
Button readinglist
Button nextapperance