Polling News

Quantifying the Trump Endorsement

November 17, 2022

Former President Trump made a point of flaunting the win rate of his endorsed candidates; however, an American Enterprise Institute study shows that in close races, his endorsement was not of great service to candidates. In most competitive races, Trump-candidates performed below expectations relative to non-Trump backed peers.

The AEI study set a trend line based on the Cook Political Report’s Partisan Voting Index (PVI), using a district’s PVI of the district as the expected performance. In 114 Congressional Districts where the race was won or lost by 15 points or less, Mr. Trump endorsed in 26 of these competitive races.  Twenty-two Trump-endorsed candidates in competitive races (84%) fell below the trend line of expected performance, 13 Trump-backed candidates in competitive races (50%) lost and of the 13 Trump-backed hopefuls who won, 9 (~70%) ran below expectations.

A Pennsylvania Case Study: In Pennsylvania’s CD 8, Democrat Cong. Matt Cartwright faced a challenge from Trump-backed Jim Bognet. The race was predicted to be tough for Cartwright, whose district PVI grew from an R+1 to R+4. However, Cartwright defeated his GOP opponent by almost 3%.

Michigan Margin: In a race rated D+1, it was expected to be close for Democrat Hillary Scholten against her Trump-backed opponent, John Gibbs. In the Republican primary, Gibbs had defeated incumbent Peter Meijer, one of 10 GOP Congressman to vote to impeach the former president. Gibbs lost the general election by over 12 points.

Bottom Line: Former President Trump’s endorsement may well have been a major source of weak performance for Republicans; the true power of an endorsement is in the meaningful general election wins it delivers.  In close races, it’s clear that those with the Trump endorsement were not granted a great advantage by it at the end of the day.

Related PollingNews

Placeholder polling news
September 11, 2025 |
Polling News
The latest CBS News/YouGov poll found that President Donald Trump’s tariffs are still in bumpy political terrain. Only his hard core base supports them. ...
Placeholder polling news
September 04, 2025 |
Polling News
A recent Pew Research Center poll found that aside from the National Park Service, National Weather Service, and USPS, Americans are divided on trust in federal institutions, split along partisan lines on most departments, particularly when it comes to IC...
Placeholder polling news
August 28, 2025 |
Polling News
Tuesday, Iowa Democrats flipped a State Senate Seat that Donald Trump carried by eleven points last November, breaking the GOP State Senate Supermajority. ...
Placeholder polling news
August 21, 2025 |
Polling News
It’s no secret that the Democratic Party is going through an identity crisis, but a New York Times analysis found that the party’s malaise has translated into tangible effects.  ...
Button karlsbooks
Button readinglist
Button nextapperance