Articles

Trump’s Echo of 1829

February 27, 2025
4088f4bc777ebd9aae25d3c1c6ed83c5

This period in American politics may seem extraordinary. Donald Trump’s critics, in particular, portray him as unprecedented.

November’s election was a comeback for the ages—a return to power of a man who maintains that his opponent stole the presidency from him four years prior. Washington’s cultural and political establishment was aghast at the heartland rabble that flocked to the inauguration.

Accompanied by a fervent army of outsiders, he wasted no time exercising his presidential authority. He promptly attacked the country’s elites in politics, media, business and culture. Antiestablishment to his core, he began firing federal employees left and right, justifying his actions with allegations of waste, fraud, abuse and incompetence.

The president’s flood of executive actions caused critical media and political opponents to depict him as a would-be king. He antagonized leaders of foreign countries—starting with Denmark—over what he felt the U.S. was due. He further infuriated global opinion by saying a neighboring country should be made a state. On the economic front, he defended high tariffs and picked a fight with the central bank over interest rates. 

But the truth is, none of this is new. America has seen it all before, nearly 200 years ago, in the person of Andrew Jackson.

Jackson’s election in 1828 was a similar repudiation of his predecessor, who he claimed had beaten him in the last cycle through “a corrupt bargain.” In 1824, Jackson won 40.5% in a four-man race, carried 11 of 24 states, and received a plurality of electoral votes. But he was 32 electors short of a majority.

When the House took up the contest in February 1825, four states flipped that had voted for Jackson in the fall. November’s second-place finisher, John Quincy Adams, grabbed 13 of 24 states and the White House. “The people” have “been cheated,” Jackson reportedly said. “Corruptions and intrigues . . . defeated the will of the people.” He decisively won a rematch four years later with Vice President John Calhoun of South Carolina as his running mate.

During Jackson’s inaugural, celebrating supporters clogged the streets, packed the Capitol to shake his hand, then mobbed the White House. One astonished local compared it to “the inundation of the northern barbarians into Rome.” You can imagine a K Street suit saying the same of MAGA crowds.

Jackson, like Mr. Trump, castigated the establishment of his time, telling his wife in 1824 he’d “save the nation from the rule of Demagogues.” Upon taking power, he immediately had longtime government employees—in his own words—“unceremoniously removed,” believing democracy would be refreshed by “rotation in office.”

Jackson wanted to increase the presidency’s power. His imperious actions and tendency to ignore Congress led opponents to caricature him in 1832 as “King Andrew the First,” wearing a crown and robes and brandishing a scepter.

He got into a dispute with Denmark and other European powers over spoliation claims for American ships seized during the Napoleonic Wars. Jackson wanted Texas—part of Mexico before it declared independence in 1836—to become a state. He presided over the “Tariff of Abominations,” levies so high that South Carolina threatened secession over them in 1832. He vehemently opposed the Second Bank of America’s high interest rates. 

Both presidents were self-obsessed personalities, strident partisans and vengeful. But there are notable differences. Jackson was a war hero; Mr. Trump isn’t. Jackson was born into poverty, Mr. Trump into wealth. Jackson wanted to prevent corruption; Mr. Trump had no qualms about issuing his own crypto while president-elect. Jackson paid off the national debt; Mr. Trump added massively to it in his first term.

Read More at the WSJ

Related Article

3d5ac0bdda3c1ed0d606cff5bd41a92c
October 09, 2025 |
Article
There’s so much happening, it’s overwhelming—for news junkies watching events unfold and for the White House trying to manage it all. ...
00a48e374a896626bf94161e12457fd0
September 25, 2025 |
Article
It looks as if we’ll have another government shutdown. On Friday House Republicans passed a continuing resolution to fund the government. In response, Senate Democrats demanded that the resolution extend Biden-era ObamaCare subsidies that soon expire. ...
D1cab95d81fde6d0a02f815b78ac93b8
September 18, 2025 |
Article
It has been a sad, sickening week for America. Our country witnessed a terrible event. A young man was gunned down doing what he loved—debating all comers on a college campus on behalf of his passionately held beliefs. ...
4cef5f0e9ca9889e328da780a78d0636
September 11, 2025 |
Article
Mike Rogers seeks to win the party a seat for the first time since 1994. ...
Button karlsbooks
Button readinglist
Button nextapperance