Articles

'Empathy' Is Code for Judicial Activism

May 27, 2009

Both President Barack Obama and Republicans get something they want from the Supreme Court nomination of Sonia Sotomayor.

Mr. Obama said he wanted to replace Justice David Souter with someone who had "empathy" and who'd temper the court's decisions with a concern for the downtrodden, the powerless and the voiceless.

"Empathy" is the latest code word for liberal activism, for treating the Constitution as malleable clay to be kneaded and molded in whatever form justices want. It represents an expansive view of the judiciary in which courts create policy that couldn't pass the legislative branch or, if it did, would generate voter backlash.

There is a certain irony in a president who routinely praises America's commitment to "the rule of law" but who picks Supreme Court nominees for their readiness to discard the rule of law whenever emotion moves them.

FULL ARTICLE: http://online.wsj.com/article/SB124347199490860831.html

Related Article

18d9eec74d36cc4091cc11f5439e75cf
November 06, 2025 |
Article
Tuesday was a very good night for Democrats, but the headlines obscure things that should worry both parties for next year’s midterms. ...
3507b73f46ee921b409e2f24240b09d4
October 30, 2025 |
Article
With days to go in the New York City mayoral contest, Democratic nominee Zohran Mamdani—often smooth and charismatic—made a real misstep. ...
16a9e5cfdb6a18d43bdf8b14db7f93d9
October 23, 2025 |
Article
When ballots are counted across America in less than two weeks, the punditry will focus on the New York mayoral race and the New Jersey and Virginia gubernatorial contests. Knowing that these races could be predictive of next year’s midterms, who won and ...
1f8c3d05de63bedccc8857ef6bf085f4
October 16, 2025 |
Article
The past week has been historic, and a great personal triumph for President Trump.    ...
Button karlsbooks
Button readinglist
Button nextapperance