Articles

Amateur Hour at the White House

February 02, 2017
76f30194ccee32300474fc182dac6d66

No one should have been surprised when President Trump followed through on his Aug. 15 campaign call for “extreme vetting” of visitors to America from dangerous parts of the globe. But the details of the president’s executive order—as well as the timing and the confusion that accompanied the rollout—are disconcerting.

The administration issued its policy Friday afternoon, a time normally used in Washington to bury bad stories. Moreover, it came unaccompanied by briefing papers and talking points, and no officials immediately explained it. It took two hours before reporters received copies of the final order—and another two before White House officials answered their questions.

The policy was effective immediately, leaving hundreds of visa holders from seven countries in limbo. Some were detained as they flew into U.S. airports from abroad, others turned back or were not allowed to board their planes overseas. The administration even applied the policy to green-card holders—legal permanent residents, most of whom have studied, worked or lived in the U.S. for years.

Chaos and controversy predictably followed. Thousands of protesters turned up at airports around the country. Lawyers rushed to courthouses and were rewarded with judicial orders hobbling the policy’s execution. The administration reversed itself a day later, allowing green-card holders to be exempted on a case-by-case basis.

Now imagine if the president had waited and implemented the policy carefully and deliberately. Mr. Trump, surrounded by the secretaries of homeland security and state, delivers a presidential speech. He announces the immediate suspension of new visas for travelers from the seven listed countries, and explains clearly why they were chosen. He directs the secretaries to develop “extreme vetting” standards within 90 days, while halting Syrian refugee flows indefinitely.

Mr. Trump then adds that current visa holders from the seven countries could still travel to the U.S.—but they would be subject to additional monitoring upon arrival. None of these new rules, he reassures Americans, apply to green-card holders. After speaking, Mr. Trump has his two secretaries field questions from the press. Congressional leaders are already well-informed and able to defend the policy, because Vice President Mike Pence gave them a heads-up before the announcement.

This probably would have produced virtually all the benefits the administration sought with much less controversy. A Quinnipiac University poll last month showed that 48% of Americans favor “suspending immigration from ‘terror prone’ regions.” Only 42% oppose it.

A well-executed decision-making process and rollout might have improved those numbers, giving the administration an early political win. There likely would have been fewer, smaller protests. There would not have been stories like the one about Hameed Khalid Darweesh. The Iraqi interpreter had received a visa to come to America after working with the U.S. military for years. He was detained at Kennedy Airport over the weekend for around 18 hours.

It’s conceivable White House aides wanted controversy, believing it helps the president by provoking hysteria among political opponents and the press. But if Mr. Trump’s critics looked bad, he came off poorly too. It helped Mr. Trump’s cause that former President Obama decided Monday—only 10 days after leaving office—to unleash his inner community organizer by publicly encouraging the protesters. No decent interval of silence for his successor from Mr. Obama.

This controversy will soon recede. Homeland Security Secretary John Kelly’s press conference Tuesday calmed the situation, and Mr. Trump’s nomination of Judge Neil M. Gorsuch to the Supreme Court will now grab the headlines.

To read more visit WSJ.com

Related Article

9dc59ecea8743220743a946a7feb74d8
February 16, 2017 |
Article
Trump’s missteps have energized the left, but tea-party comparisons are overwrought. ...
E66e1979d9fdeeb91782e5247187be9a
February 09, 2017 |
Article
What ‘sanctuary cities’ have in common with 1832 South Carolina. ...
61d5413c290571bb16c3ac4d80c35704
January 26, 2017 |
Article
Democrats are holding up Trump’s cabinet nominees in a way the GOP didn’t in 2009. ...
0edc0cb4671452c5f3a9cf401078410a
January 19, 2017 |
Article
Donald J. Trump is about to be sworn in as America’s 45th president, after an astonishing victory in an extraordinary election. Mr. Trump’s insurgency first prevailed against a broad field of Republican heavyweights. Then the tycoon faced the formidable C...
Button karlsbooks
Button readinglist
Button nextapperance